Safe to say Batman has come a long way since the days of Adam West and Burt Ward. He’s cooler, tougher, and thank goodness he doesn’t wear spandex anymore. But in addition to giving up the tights and corny bat-gadgets, Batman has become darker.
The Dark Knight opened at 12:01 AM Friday morning, July 18. It’s the second installment in director/writer Christopher Nolan’s fresh take on the Batman franchise and it’s already being hailed as a masterpiece in the comic book and crime drama genres. “Masterpiece” may be slightly higher praise than this film deserves; I can’t help wondering if actor Heath Ledger’s tragic death earlier this year has influenced critics’ perceptions of the movie as a whole (Ledger’s individual performance is masterful).
Nolan’s brooding superhero flick definitely earns its PG-13 rating. The violence is brutal, the villains grotesque, and the tone gloomy. This incarnation of Batman’s (Christian Bale) encounter with the Joker (Ledger) abandons the fun quirkiness of Tim Burton’s 1989 Batman; instead it tackles serious questions about the true natures of morality and heroism.
Ledger’s brilliantly performed Joker does not ask for, or evoke, empathy. He doesn’t have a single sob story—he has several, each different from the one before. There’s no justifying his madness or sadistic behavior. To him, Gotham City is a giant toy, one that squirms and writhes under the pressure of evil. Joker is a devout moral relativist. As he explains to Gotham district attorney Harvey Dent (Aaron Eckhart),
I’m a dog chasing cars. I don’t have plans. I just do things. I’m not a schemer.
With villains it is tempting to look beyond their actions in search of a broken past or haunting trauma that morphed them into their current state. We want to feel sympathy for them—because that means they’re redeemable. Not the Joker. Ecclesiastes 8:8 explains that “wickedness will not release those who practice it.” The evil festering in Joker’s mind and soul is so complete it’s pure.
Joker desires anarchy, a world with no rules. He seeks to achieve it by destroying the moral codes of Gotham’s citizens and heroes. Story-tellers, particularly those dealing with superheroes, seem to show a penchant for pushing protagonists to their limits in terms of right-or-wrong. How far will Batman go to stop the Joker? Will he commit murder, rather than bring the madman under the justice of the law of the land? Who will he choose to save? Who will the civilians of Gotham choose to save—themselves or others?
1 Corinthians 15:33 reminds us, “Do not be misled: ‘Bad company corrupts good character.’” Just minutes in the company of Joker reveals cracks in the moral armor of Batman and his allies. The vicious psychopath’s mutterings work like poison. But Scripture also provides a remedy: “Submit yourselves, then, to God. Resist the devil, and he will flee from you.”
Of course, no one in this movie even mentions God—except to use his name in vain—but this brings up an intriguing point.
All hopes are pinned on Batman to rescue Gotham from evil. Bruce Wayne’s butler Alfred (Michael Caine) tells him,
You can be the outcast. You can make the choice that no one else will face—the right choice.
Batman can save people from other men’s evil intent, but he cannot save them from the consequences of the evil in their own hearts. Though superheroes, like Batman and Superman, are often touted as modern symbols for saviors, there’s been only one person in all of history that actually has the power to offer forgiveness of sins and salvation.
Jesus Christ blew the religious leaders of his day away when he forgave the sins of the paralytic in Capernaum. Mark writes that “some teachers of the law were sitting there, thinking to themselves, ‘Why does this fellow talk like that? He’s blaspheming! Who can forgive sins but God alone?’”
But Jesus reminds them that “‘the Son of Man has authority on earth to forgive sins.’” Christ’s identity is paramount to his authority. He is God Incarnate and, thus, embodies God’s full power. Yet Jesus is also human. Kenneth Samples describes Christ’s unique identity in A World of Difference:
…Jesus Christ is therefore “two Whats” (a divine “what” [or nature] and a human “what” [or nature]) and “one Who” (a single “person” or “self”). As God Incarnate, Jesus retained all of his divine attributes through his divine nature, and yet through his human nature was fully human.
This is what makes Christ the perfect hero. His full divinity exclusively allows him the power to forgive humans of their sins and to “qualif[y] [them] to share in the inheritance of the saints in the kingdom of light.”. But his full humanity allows him to relate to the suffering of people and to make a proper atoning sacrifice on mankind’s behalf.
Culturally, we’ve had a love affair with fallen heroes and antiheroes in our stories. We love to describe the fallen state as showing the characters’ humanity, it makes them more real. So, where does that leave Jesus? Does his sinless life make him less human and more divine? On the contrary, Jesus’ resistance against temptation and his perfect obedience to the law reveals him to be more human than we are. It exposes a righteousness that should have been ours, had we not thrown it away.
Because of Christ’s work on our behalf death has lost its sting. And that is the victory of the ultimate hero.